Cross-examination

But what about Meres, 1598?

  1. The claim

    In Palladis Tamia (1598), Francis Meres praised Shakespeare as the English Ovid and listed twelve of his plays, several of them not printed until 1623. Meres plainly knew who wrote them.

  2. The short answer

    Meres is among the strongest lifetime sources, and the book does not doubt that he believed what he wrote. But he names the authorial name and The Works, not The Man: no Stratford detail, no family, no stated basis of knowledge. Granting that his Shakespeare is The Stratford Man makes Meres evidence of a career; citing Meres as proof of that identification returns the premise as its own proof.

  3. The full cross-examination

    The claim in its strongest form, the documents behind it, and the book's complete answer are in Chapter Three, section 3.4.

    Get notified when it's out
← All objections Still not convinced? Challenge it