Authorship Chain 25 of 25
Shakspere of Stratford
1564–1616
- One end · Recoverable historical individual
Stratford and London individual: Blackfriars Gatehouse instruments, 1613; will
- The independent connection
None established. The patent and will join him to the company only
- Other end · Recoverable authorial identity · the literary activity
Attribution under the name in his lifetime: dedications, title pages, Meres, Davies
Independent connection: a lifetime record connecting a recoverable historical individual to literary activity. It must be personal and discriminating, not impersonal or posthumous, and it must make the connection independently, not depend on the attribution being tested. Every one of the twenty-five chains is held to it. The full definition →
Why it does not close
Both ends are secure, and nothing in his lifetime record joins them independently: the patent and will tie The Man to the company, not to the writing.
The full case record
Documents, sources and the reasoning for each link are in the book, and in the Research Packet for scholars.
Get notified when it's outWhere to check itLMA CLC/522/MS03738; BL Egerton 1787; TNA C54/2184 no.45; PROB 1/4; Meres, Nn6v–Oo4r; Davies, epigram 159
His lifetime sources, and why each falls short
| Lifetime source | What it gives | Why it does not complete the connection |
|---|---|---|
| Company records (1595 payment, 1603 patent) | The name among the players | Proof of professional proximity; no writing role stated |
| Venus and Adonis, Lucrece dedications (1593–94) | First-person address to a patron under the name William Shakespeare | Serious literary evidence, but no particular joins the name to the Stratford person, and the grant cannot supply one |
| Title pages | The name attached to works | Mediated by stationers; records attribution, not a civic individual |
| Meres (1598) | Names poems and twelve plays | Specific about works; nothing about the person or how he knew |
| Revels accounts (1604–05) | “Shaxberd” under poets who made the plays | Authenticity disputed. Even if accepted, impersonal: no Stratford detail or stated basis of knowledge |
| Davies ([1611]) | “Our English Terence”, addressed by name as player and writer | Names no work and gives no basis of knowledge; “player” identifies an occupation, not an act of composition |
| Howes (1615) | “M. Willi. Shakespeare gentleman” among the excellent poets | Repeats the attribution: no work, no Stratford detail, no personal knowledge; “gentleman” is used as a courtesy across the list |
| Chettle (1592) | Praises an unnamed person's “grace in writing” | Subject unnamed and disputed; the praise is reported from others |
| Hand D (Sir Thomas More) | Possible composing hand | Disputed and not conclusive: the comparison sample is six signatures. Important evidence, but not secured as his hand |
The clearest convergence comes after his death: the monument and the 1623 Folio, with Jonson, Digges, Heminges and Condell. That is substantial positive evidence. By the rule applied to all twenty-five, it can strengthen a lifetime connection but cannot originate one.
One qualifying lifetime connection would overturn this finding. If Hand D were securely his hand and showed composing or substantive revision, the finding would be withdrawn.